Are You Under-leading Your Organization?

Written by Leigh Bailey

As CEO, there’s a pivotal question you must be able to answer: Why were you chosen to lead your organization? And more importantly, where can you uniquely lead your company that no other CEO can?

If you’re unable to answer these questions, you may be under-leading your organization.

Understanding Your Unique Value as CEO

CEOs are chosen for a reason—there is something about you that convinced the board you were the right choice. It could be your ability to inspire and build confidence among external stakeholders, your specialized industry knowledge, or your talent for bringing alignment and structure to a fragmented executive leadership team (ELT).

These are not hypothetical reasons. These examples are drawn from real CEOs we’ve worked with. Discovering the real reason you were chosen may take time, but rest assured, there was a compelling reason you were selected.

The Responsibility of CEO Leadership

Becoming CEO grants you a unique opportunity and responsibility. Effective leadership demands the courage to develop a vision and strategy in consultation with your board and ELT, and then execute relentlessly. Establishing this vision is not a consensus exercise—it’s about your willingness to take the organization where only you can lead it, leveraging your personality, experience, and judgment.

Avoid the Trap of Under-Leading

Many CEOs struggle with this fundamental aspect of leadership. Some mistakenly believe that the only way to gain buy-in is through consensus, leading to indecision. In reality, your team often expects you to make a decisive choice, so the organization can move forward with clarity and purpose.

Others hesitate to act due to a lack of perfect knowledge, particularly when addressing underperforming ELT members. By delaying action, CEOs risk losing respect, enabling damaging behavior, and missing opportunities for a fresh start.

Moving Forward with Confidence

Reflect on where you want to lead your organization, write it down, and share it with your team. Seek input, but remember, it’s your role to make the final decision and start executing.

At The Bailey Group, we help CEOs ensure they aren’t under-leading. If you think this might be an issue for you, let’s grab a coffee and talk about it.

Published 2024
Topics: Growth, Leadership, Strategy

More articles

She Was Already a Strong Leader. Coaching Helped Her Lead at a Whole New Level.

She Was Already a Strong Leader. Coaching Helped Her Lead at a Whole New Level.

The challenge: Stepping into the enterprise leadership role After years of experience in human resources, this...
No Leader Is an Island: Why Community and Feedback Are the Real Leadership Skills of 2026

No Leader Is an Island: Why Community and Feedback Are the Real Leadership Skills of 2026

Sal Mondelli (With apologies to poet John Donne) You probably met “No Man Is an Island”...
Why Every CEO Needs an Executive Coach: The Data Behind Accelerating Success in 2026

Why Every CEO Needs an Executive Coach: The Data Behind Accelerating Success in 2026

We meet successful CEOs and C-suite leaders every day, and almost all of them got the...
What Is Executive Coaching, and How Does It Work?

What Is Executive Coaching, and How Does It Work?

Quick answer: Executive Coaching is a confidential, one-on-one partnership that helps leaders build self-awareness, work through...
Why Your Team Keeps Repeating the Same Conversations (And What’s Actually Blocking Progress)

Why Your Team Keeps Repeating the Same Conversations (And What’s Actually Blocking Progress)

You’ve explained it in the meeting. You followed up by email. Someone asked the exact same...
How Leaders Can Better Assess Fit, Potential, and Coachability

How Leaders Can Better Assess Fit, Potential, and Coachability

Most leaders trust their gut when it comes to people. Sometimes that works. After nearly 30...
Morning Momentum: You Don’t Have to Lead Alone

Morning Momentum: You Don’t Have to Lead Alone

On Wednesday, The Bailey Group and Lakeside HR brought together an impressive group of CEOs and...
Accountability Resources

Accountability Resources

Accountability is one of the most critical – and most misunderstood – drivers of organizational performance....
Are Your Values Worth Another Conversation?

Are Your Values Worth Another Conversation?

This summer, executive teams everywhere will head to the woods, a resort, or a thoughtfully chosen...